Mississippi News
The Mississippi Republican income tax bet
The Mississippi Republican income tax bet
Note: This analysis first published in Mississippi Today's weekly legislative newsletter. Subscribe to our free newsletter for exclusive early access to weekly analyses.
Mississippi faces a critical teacher shortage due in part to lawmakers paying them less than any other state. Meanwhile, many of the teachers we do have don't have the classroom resources — and sometimes even actual classrooms — they need to adequately teach their students.
Agencies that provide critical government services are hemorrhaging staff because state employee salaries have been so low for so long that staffers are entering the more lucrative private sector.
Businesses across the state struggle to attract and retain workers because the prospective workers often lack the specific education or skills necessary to do those jobs effectively.
Aging roads, closed bridges and broken water systems are disrupting the everyday lives of so many Mississippians. Police and ambulance services are reporting staff shortages that could jeopardize the ability to provide timely emergency attention. Hospital leaders are begging lawmakers to help keep them afloat as they continue struggling to weather the pandemic.
Mississippi's house is not in order. Mississippians across the state are struggling. They've been struggling. But these realities appear to have escaped Republican leaders inside the Capitol.
Speaker of the House Philip Gunn is exerting every ounce of political capital he has to eliminate the Mississippi personal income tax, which accounts for about one-third of the state's general fund revenue to fund basic government services like the ones listed above. In response, Lt. Gov. Delbert Hosemann offered a shallower income tax cut, but one that many believe also threatens the state's ability to fund basic public services.
“We have done everything,” Gunn said recently. “We have funded all of the government. We have excess money. Let's give it back.”
READ MORE: Inside the income tax cut battle between House and Senate leaders
Mississippi currently has more money than it ever has. Revenue is currently soaring, thanks in large part to federal stimulus dollars that have poured into the state — both to individuals and to the state government. Many are calling this moment a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to address some systemic problems the state has long faced. Others are just calling it once in a lifetime.
Republican leaders aren't walking onto the floor of the Beau Rivage, but they sure look poised to place the biggest bet of their lives. To sell their income tax cut proposals, they're pointing to projections that are based solely on the best guesses of economists. Keep in mind, these projections are often very wrong because they are guesses. (This current fiscal year, revenue collections will likely be about $1 billion off last year's “best guess.”)
The bet Republicans are making, in essence, is that Mississippians will spend the income tax money they're “saving” them in other ways, and that other tax collections will rise. No state has ever fully phased out a personal income tax, so there's true way to know if this bet will pay off.
If they're right, the Mississippi state government will continue to be funded. If they're wrong, government budgets will have to be slashed to balance the state budget and Mississippians will miss out on even more basic government services that they're already not getting enough of.
The prevailing question that everyone is asking as they watch how legislative leaders navigate the next few weeks: Can Mississippi really afford this tax cut?
Ask teachers, who have long been underappreciated and underpaid by lawmakers. Gunn and Hosemann are pushing their own versions of a pretty substantial pay raise for teachers that will cost the state about $200 million more per year. Education groups aren't so sure the pay raises — not withstanding basic public education services — will be funded in perpetuity if this tax cut bet doesn't pay off.
“If Mississippi has plenty of money, the Legislature has no excuse for not fully funding public schools and bringing teacher pay to the Southeastern average — before giving away any state funds,” wrote Nancy Loome of public education advocacy group The Parents' Campaign. “If Mississippi does not have sufficient state funds to properly provide for our children and teachers, we certainly can't afford a tax cut.”
Ask retirees, a majority of whom don't currently pay income tax, what they think about having to pay a higher sales tax on many of the things they spend their money on. Ask advocates for lower-income Mississippians, who could likely pay more in taxes if the Gunn plan is adopted.
“The (tax cut proposal) is like putting lipstick on a pig. No matter how you dress it up or down, eliminating the income tax is bad for Mississippi, especially the state's working families, communities of color, and retirees,” advocacy group One Voice wrote in January. “The state's surplus is not enough to support much-needed investments in the public services that Mississippians want, like quality schools, affordable healthcare, solid infrastructure, safe neighborhoods, and affordable housing nor is it enough to support yet another tax cut that largely benefits the state's wealthiest.”
Ask the leaders of Mississippi's largest businesses, who continue to publicly maintain that cutting the income tax will not help them attract and retain a better workforce.
“The Mississippi tax environment was not high profile nor even discussed significantly as a priority,” said a report released by the Mississippi Economic Council last week. To compile that report, MEC held 51 town-hall style forums with business and community leaders across the state and from numerous sectors from July through September of 2021. The income tax issue didn't even come up at any meeting until the end of August.
“There was the thought (eliminating the income tax) could drive other costs up and it could hurt the state budget and households,” the business council's report said.
The Tax Foundation, a conservative think-tank, said that Mississippians paid $614 per capita for income taxes in 2020. That's a nice chunk of change that no one would turn down. But considering so many government services aren't already provided, what would that extra spending money really look like for Mississippians? Is it real relief?
For teachers, it could be some extra money to buy their students classroom supplies and teaching resources that aren't covered by the state. For drivers, it could be a new set of tires that need replacing because the roads are in such bad shape. It could provide some relief for Mississippians who pay higher water bills as systems continue requiring costly repairs, or higher medical bills because understaffed hospitals will have to drive up costs.
For Mississippians looking for better jobs, it could be tuition money for the skills training that they can't currently get in their county, or gas money to drive long distances to places where the jobs actually exist.
The income tax money that taxpayers would be “saved” would, in many cases, have to be spent plugging holes that lawmakers have left themselves — Mississippians forced to spend money they wouldn't otherwise have to because lawmakers didn't do their jobs well in the first place.
While Republican leaders continue to use best guesses to allay all these concerns, Mississippians may soon be forced to watch their big bet play out over the course of the next few years. And the stakes sure will be high.
This article first appeared on Mississippi Today and is republished here under a Creative Commons license.
Mississippi News
Three Northeast Mississippi players receive MHSAA Miss Softball honors
SUMMARY: The MHSAA announced the annual Miss Softball winners, with three recipients coming from Northeast Mississippi who are currently competing for a state championship. In the 3A category, Mantachie's Ramsey Montgomery won the award with impressive batting and pitching statistics. Lucy Cochran from East Union won the 2A award for the second consecutive season, showcasing exceptional pitching and hitting skills. Emma Mayer from Myrtle was recognized in the 1A category for her outstanding hitting performance this season. All three players have excelled in their respective categories and are contributing significantly to their teams' success in the playoffs.
The post Three Northeast Mississippi players receive MHSAA Miss Softball honors appeared first on www.wcbi.com
Mississippi News
Humid next few days with storm potential at times – Home – WCBI TV
SUMMARY: An increase in humidity is expected in Columbus, Mississippi over the next couple of days, with storm chances likely on Wednesday night. Tuesday will be warm and breezy with a few showers and storms possible in the afternoon, some of which may become locally strong. Wednesday will see the potential for widespread showers and storms in the evening as a strong cold front moves through, with the possibility of severe weather. However, nicer weather is expected for the weekend with gradual clearing on Friday and drier conditions on Saturday, although isolated showers may return on Sunday into Monday.
The post Humid next few days with storm potential at times – Home – WCBI TV appeared first on www.wcbi.com
Mississippi News
JSU welcomes new Women’s Basketball coach
SUMMARY: Margaret Richards has been named the new head coach for the Jackson State Women's Basketball team, marking a new era for the Lady Tigers. Richards previously coached at Alabama A&M for eight years before joining Mercer's staff. She is excited for the new challenge and looks forward to meeting alumni and continuing the team's tradition and history. Richards replaced Tomekia Reed, who left to become the head coach for the Charlotte 49ers. She is eager to hit the ground running and build upon the success of the team.
The post JSU welcomes new Women's Basketball coach appeared first on www.wjtv.com
-
SuperTalk FM4 days ago
Driver’s education set to become mandatory in Mississippi as bill passes
-
SuperTalk FM3 days ago
State approves $160M to expand Highway 7 to four lanes in Lafayette County
-
Mississippi Business6 days ago
Geartek expanding operations in Alcorn County
-
Mississippi News6 days ago
Two women accused of shoplifting across southeast captured in Mississippi
-
Mississippi News5 days ago
Altercation at Mississippi police department leads to officer-involved shooting
-
Mississippi News1 day ago
Winston Co. Sheriff’s Office investigates shooting at Dave’s Club
-
Mississippi News6 days ago
Starkville police make arrest in shooting at Dawg Wash South
-
Mississippi Today2 days ago
On this day in 1917